Finalize Your College List With These 7 Expert Tips

How do you know when your list of colleges to apply to is final, complete, done? These seven expert tips will help you figure it out.

You’ve decided between small colleges and big colleges. Between colleges in the city and colleges in the country. But how do you know when your list of colleges to apply to is final, complete, 100% done?

We asked experts who specialize in helping students apply to college. Below you’ll find their seven signs you can be confident with your final college list. 

1. Don’t worry about a “magic number.”

You’ve probably heard that you need to apply to X safety schools, X dream schools, and X schools that are a perfect match. That’s not necessarily true. Your college list is set “when you feel comfortable and confident that each school fits your criteria,” says Mark Montgomery of Great College Advice. Maybe that means you’re applying to six colleges. Or 10. Or two. That being said…

2. Can you reasonably expect to get into the colleges and universities on your list?

Compare your grades and test scores with the most recent average admitted student’s stats. If your numbers fall into that range, it’s a good sign the school belongs on your final list.

3. Would you be excited about going to your safety schools?

Of course you’d be ecstatic about going to your dream college. But think about your safety school (or schools). Do they have everything you’re looking for? Would you be proud to wear that hoodie? If you said “yes,” Montgomery says that’s a sign you have a final college list you can feel good about.

4. Do you feel comfortable at all the schools you’re applying to?

Think about how you learn best, advises Stuart Nachbar, college counselor with Educated Quest. Maybe you need small classes or think most clearly when you’re out in nature. Each college you apply to should have whatever will help you be most successful.

5. Would you find your niche at each school?

Think about how you felt when visiting campus. Could you find the quirky, musically inclined, fitness-minded, or politically active crowd of students you want to be around? That’s important because college is about so much more than going to class. “It’s hard to succeed in college when you don’t make friends,” Nachbar says. “When you get a degree, you should have a network that will help you for the rest of your life.”

6. Do all of the colleges have what you want?

What are you hoping to get out of college? A top-quality finance degree and the chance to be recruited by Fortune 500 companies? Connection with a strong faith-based community? Preparation for medical school? Clarity on exactly what your major should even be? Nachbar stresses that each college on your list needs to be able to help you reach your specific goals.

7. Remember that life happens!

A volunteer experience might awaken an interest in a totally new major, a torn ACL might keep you from running track, or a sick family member might make you rethink traveling 3,000 miles away for college. In any case, don’t be afraid to tweak your final college list. “The reality is that things can change at any time,” Montgomery says. If that’s the case, it’s fine to add or subtract from your list. Just make sure you’re applying to colleges that fit the criteria above and will help you reach your goals.

If you’ve already applied to your colleges and universities and are wondering how to choose between your acceptances, you can find helpful tips here. (And if you’re still trying to find the perfect colleges, start here.)

Like what you’re reading?

Join the CollegeXpress community! Create a free account and we’ll notify you about new articles, scholarship deadlines, and more.

Join Now

Join our community of
over 5 million students!

CollegeXpress has everything you need to simplify your college search, get connected to schools, and find your perfect fit.

Join CollegeXpress
Leah Maciel

Leah Maciel

High School Class of 2021

CollegeXpress has helped me with all aspects of applying for college. The website is extremely easy to navigate and gives access to so many resources. I was able to research all of the colleges I was interested in, find out any information I wished to know about, and keep them organized in a list. I've also been able to research scholarships and save them as resources for later. I've used many websites in my college and scholarship search, and CollegeXpress has by far been my favorite one to use.



High School Class of 2021

CollegeXpress has helped me greatly during my college search. I used their college search feature often and it helped in comparing schools I was looking at. Now that I’ve found a college the scholarship search feature is helping me find a way to find my college experience. CollegeXpress has many helpful features and resources for anyones college search, it truly is a wonderful tool for anyone entering college level!

Lydia Huth

Lydia Huth

Student, Campbell University; CollegeXpress Student Writer

I discovered CollegeXpress while embarking on my college search journey as an excited—but scared and way confused—high schooler without a counselor or college-bound sibling to give me advice. Let me tell you, I’m so glad that I stumbled on this community! CollegeXpress helped me find potential colleges and keep application deadlines straight. It gave me a great list of scholarships, and the blogs and emails made me feel like I wasn’t going it alone. Almost three years later and with freshman year of college down, I still love the CollegeXpress vibe so much that I’m writing for them. I’d recommend this site to anyone!

Emilie Delgado

Emilie Delgado

$2,000 Community Service Scholarship Winner, 2013

CollegeXpress has tremendously helped me in my search for financial aid opportunities as I enter my college career. It is easy to navigate and quickly narrowed down scholarships that I could apply for. Being awarded the scholarship will greatly help me in my finances regarding books and tuition. Thank you for this opportunity. Without CollegeXpress, it would have been more difficult to apply. I would recommend this site to everyone!



High School Class of 2019

CollegeXpress has helped me by opening my eyes to new opportunities. I learned about such easy ways to get financial help to achieve my dreams while also learning about myself and who I truly am. I know this isn't a very long explanation of what CollegeXpress has done for me, but nonetheless, I believe it's crucial to how I developed as a person throughout my time as a college student.

College Matches

Colleges You May Be Interested In

Madonna University

Livonia, MI

Bryant University

Smithfield, RI

High Point University

High Point, NC

Rider University

Lawrenceville, NJ