Affirmative Action Still a Pressing Issue in College Admission

An update on the Fisher vs. University of Texas case taking place at the Supreme Court.

An update on the Fisher v. University of Texas case

Supreme CourtChief Justice John Roberts Jr. of the Supreme Court, who heard oral arguments regarding the Fisher v. University of Texas case this past Wednesday, wants to know how much diversity is enough and when will colleges achieve an acceptable level of diversity without using race as a preference in admission. These two questions are pressing issues in the Supreme Court decision, Fisher v. University of Texas, an ongoing affirmative-action case that was recently brought to the Supreme Court.

All justices of the Supreme Court heard oral arguments last Wednesday about the use of race in college admission at the University of Texas. The question on everybody’s mind is, “Does race-conscious college admission violate rights of some white applicants who could possibly have that accepted spot?”

The state of Texas enacted the Top 10% Law, which made it so that every Texas state university had to admit a student who finished in the top 10% in a Texas high school. This law was put into place after 1996 when a judge disagreed with an admission policy that used race as a factor. This policy is still in effect today and it accounts for the majority of student admission in Texas state universities and plays a large role in the school’s diversity plans.

In a New York Times article this past Wednesday, it was said that Chief Justice Roberts asked the lawyers in the room (both from the University of Texas and the federal government) many questions that were not answered. He asked, “What is the critical mass of African-Americans and Hispanics at the university that you are working toward?” Chief Justice Roberts just wanted a percentage and these lawyers couldn’t give that to him.

Due to the lawyers’ unwillingness to directly answer this question and to give the chief justice a percentage goal that they hoped to work towards, the court was left with not much to do regarding the court’s precedents requiring judges to look more closely when the government draws differences among people based on race.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the bottom line of this case comes down to one question: “At what point . . . do we stop deferring to the university’s judgment that race is still necessary?”

At the end of the argument this past Wednesday, it was clear that the more conservative wing of the Supreme Court justices (which includes four members) wanted to act immediately to revise the 2003 Grutter Supreme Court decision to consider race in public university admission, according to an article in The New York Times. However, the more liberal wing of the Supreme Court justices (which includes five members) said that there is no evidence or reason to throw away or amend the Grutter decision.

Since Justice Elena Kagan disqualified herself from the Fisher v. University of Texas case, this leaves room for a possible 4-4 tie and would mean that they would use a lower-court decision for deciding the outcome of this case.

College diversity can play a large part in the college admissions process, but when is the line drawn and how can universities ensure that all students are receiving a fair chance at admission?

Like what you’re reading?

Join the CollegeXpress community! Create a free account and we’ll notify you about new articles, scholarship deadlines, and more.

Join Now

Tags:
admissions Affirmative Action campus diversity college admissions college affirmative action college diversity Fisher vs UT Supreme Court University of Texas University of Texas case

About Sarah Anolik

Sarah Anolik

Sarah Anolik is a junior at Boston University, studying in the College of Communication. She is majoring in magazine journalism, minoring in psychology, and aspires to write for a magazine or newspaper someday (more specifically, ELLE magazine in New York City!). She was born and raised in Rochester, New York, but is a true Boston sports fan! Sarah is involved in BU’s school newspaper, The Daily Free Press, as a staff photographer. Additionally, she was elected to be her Greek organization’s Historian, the appointed photographer. Aside from photography, Sarah enjoys writing, shopping, and exercising.

 

Join our community of
over 5 million students!

CollegeXpress has everything you need to simplify your college search, get connected to schools, and find your perfect fit.

Join CollegeXpress
Maya Ingraham

Maya Ingraham

October 2021 Mini Scholarship Winner, Class of 2022

CollegeXpress has given me more confidence in my college process. With easy-to-access resources and guidance such as the CX Weekly Roundup, I have been able to find the best colleges for me. Most importantly, there’s a surplus of scholarship opportunities for every student to support their education.

Asia Stockdale

Asia Stockdale

High School Class of 2021

CollegeXpress helped me overcome a huge hurdle. Because of the small town I live in, I felt like I would never achieve more. I felt like I could never go beyond because of costs. I feared I wouldn’t be able to find scholarships. I had no idea of where to start. With CollegeXpress, I easily found scholarships—they came to me. It was a helper, and I was instantly matched with opportunities to go above and beyond educationally.

Nazira Abdelkhalek

Nazira Abdelkhalek

$2,000 Community Service Scholarship Winner, 2014

I am very honored to be this year’s recipient of the Multicultural Student Community Service Scholarship! This scholarship is vital to helping me achieve and fulfill my dreams, and gives me confidence and motivation as I begin my college career. The CollegeXpress website has been invaluable over the past year as I planned my educational and professional goals. I highly recommend it to all students as they begin to focus on their college and career interests. The website is a wonderful guide to schools and scholarships.

Rayan Hamdan

Rayan Hamdan

High School Student

I joined CollegeXpress just a few months ago. I had been struggling with severe anxiety, causing me to not be able to tour schools and make sure a college would be perfect for me. I came across CollegeXpress one day when I was searching for colleges online, and it completely changed the game. I was easily able to choose colleges that would suit me, and I also entered a few giveaways! Thank you so much!

Alexandria

Alexandria

High School Class of 2021

For a long time, I've been searching everywhere to find the perfect website I can get scholarships and information from. Needless to say, I could never find the right one. That was, until I found CollegeXpress. Through my journey of finding the right scholarships for me, I was able to find articles about different things. They've all been helpful, especially in times like this! I was even able to connect with some of my favorite colleges! I love CollegeXpress. Thank you!

College Matches