White woman in pink shirt at white desk with laptop, arms up in excitement

How to Build the Perfect College List in High School

Whether you're an underclassman at the start of your search or a senior about to apply, these tips will help you organize and make your final college list.

You may be an eighth grader who already has your dream college picked out, or you might be going into senior year and still have no clue what you’re doing in terms of college applications. Chances are, you’re probably somewhere in between. In any case, making a college list is a good idea. It’s nice to keep your options open while still having a pretty good plan of what you’ll be doing come college application season. Wherever you are in the college search process, here are some ideas and tips that may be able to help!

Making a college list should be fun

This is the most important tip: ensure you have the right mindset. Sometimes researching college feels like a task you have to do for school or something you need to do in order to be successful (which isn’t necessarily a bad thing). Think of making your college list as exploring your options, an adventure on the internet to find out where you might want to be in a few years. And remember: relax. This isn’t something you need to cause yourself unnecessary stress about...don’t you have that history test next week for that?

When should you begin?

Many people say that “now” is a good time and “it’s never too early to start planning for college!” They aren’t wrong…but at the same time, it’s also never too late to look at schools either. For me, some of the colleges on my list were ones I decided I was going to apply to around freshman year. Others—two out of six, actually—I never even considered applying to until September and October of my senior year (a little more on that later).

Related: 8 Advantages of Starting Your College Search Early

Keep your options open

As my marching band director likes to say, “The march is a living, breathing entity.” For those of you musicians out there, your band or orchestra director has probably told you something along those lines, right? When it comes to the music, it isn’t just played over and over. Every rehearsal brings something new to the music: a crescendo here, a fortsando there. Maybe a new chord, or a fermata for additional drama. Whether you understood my analogy or not, the same goes for your college list. Your list is never complete—it’s not something you write up then leave alone and can’t touch for years. Sure, it’s good to have a starting point, but the initial colleges you choose won’t necessarily be the ones you feel are right for you when you do end up applying. Of course, you’ll hear new names that you might want to look into...and if they seem right for you, it’s a good idea to put them on the list.

Definitely, maybe, probably not…

That’s not quite the saying, but I would suggest having three different categories on your list: Definitely, Maybe, and Probably Not. Don’t be shy to shift schools between the three categories! Especially if your list is typed, all you need to do is copy and paste your information into a different category. These categories are pretty self-explanatory, but here are my short little qualifications for each.

Related: How to Pick Your Safety, Reach, and Match Colleges

"Definitely" schools

This school checks most (or all!) of your boxes; as of right now, they are one of your top choices. (I would keep about four to eight schools in this category, though it’s totally up to you!)

"Maybe" schools

This school checks most of your boxes, but you’re not entirely sure how much you would love it. (Tip: If you haven’t already, you should try to visit these schools in person to get a better feel!) Once the time comes, you might apply, but you might not.

"Probably not" schools

This school checks some of your boxes, but you're not super excited about it. Still, though, it's important to be open-minded and give yourself options. (I put schools that I wouldn’t put anywhere else on the list in this category.) All the schools you ultimately apply to should be ones that you’d be happy to attend if you get accepted! So if you could never see yourself happy there—even as a safety school/backup plan—leave it off your list entirely.

What should you include on your list?

Universities and colleges, of course! I kept basic information on the list so I had a quick facts sheet (you can normally just copy and paste from the college’s admission page or the College Board or CollegeXpress profile). Our College Search Spreadsheet Template is a great way to get organized and keep track of all the important factors to you!

Related: How to Stay Organized in Your College Search

See? Making your college list isn't as hard as it seems. If you're an underclassman, it's never too early to start and really give yourself time to figure out what you want. And if you're a senior, it's never too early to get it together and find a great college to attend next year. Now go forth and conquer...we believe in you!

Find more great articles and advice on the college search process in our College Admission section!

Like what you’re reading?

Join the CollegeXpress community! Create a free account and we’ll notify you about new articles, scholarship deadlines, and more.

Join Now

Tags:

Join our community of
over 5 million students!

CollegeXpress has everything you need to simplify your college search, get connected to schools, and find your perfect fit.

Join CollegeXpress

College Quick Connect

Swipe right to request information.
Swipe left if you're not interested.

Colorado State University

Fort Collins, CO


Katie

Katie

High School Class of 2019

My favorite feature of CollegeXpress is the scholarship search. As someone going out of state for college, I needed all the financial help I could get, and CollegeXpress helped me easily find scholarships I could apply for to help fund my education.

Sadie Hartmann

Sadie Hartmann

High School Class of 2021

I'm a senior in high school, and CollegeXpress has helped me in so many ways this year in trying to navigate the process of deciding and committing to a university. The COVID-19 Student Resource Center has helped me many times with the most up-to-date and accurate information, along with financial aid and student life [advice]. During these uncertain times, CollegeXpress has been a great recourse to relieve the stress as a senior. Along with the COVID-19 Student Resource Center, I'm constantly using the extremely helpful tools off the site to aid me during this stressful process. Tools like the lists and rankings of universities have been the most beneficial. I've also used the site to receive expert advice on topics like financial aid. Finally, CollegeXpress has helped me easily apply for several scholarships. I'm thankful to be given the chance to win a scholarship to lessen the burden of my college debt.

Khush

Khush

High School Class of 2021

CollegeXpress is a multi-maneuver platform that has been helping students in their college applications and scholarship hunt process. For me, CollegeXpress has been a boon. I've been able to find my dream university via CX, and I've also been able to apply to thousands of scholarships through it. All the thanks to CollegeXpress for doing such a great job for free. I express my sincere gratitude to you for doing such a wonderful job. I recommend CollegeXpress without any reservations.

Chris Bell

Chris Bell

Bell College Consulting

The college lists on CollegeXpress are indispensable for sussing out creative additions to a student’s list, and the college-specific pages provide terrific commentary and suggestions for related schools. CollegeXpress is among the most trusted sources I use for information for my students.

Melanie Kajy

Melanie Kajy

High School Class of 2021

CollegeXpress has helped me tremendously during my senior year of high school. I started off using the college search to find more information about the universities I was interested in. Just this tool alone gave me so much information about a particular school. It was my one-stop shop to learn about college. I was able to find information about college tuition, school rank, majors, and so much more that I can't list it all. The college search tool has helped me narrow down which college I want to attend, and it made a stressful process surprisingly not so stressful. I then moved to the scholarship search tool to find scholarships to apply for because I can't afford to pay for tuition myself. The search tool helped me find scholarships that I was eligible for. The tool gave me all the information I could ever need about a particular scholarship that was being offered. The CollegeXpress scholarship search tool is so much better than other tools offered, like the Chegg scholarship search. Thanks to CollegeXpress, I was able to apply to tons of scholarships in a relatively easy way!